Saturday, September 29, 2012

Between legal and illegal mining there is just this 'ill'


Reading Sept 29 newspapers in Goa make for interesting reading, and one can easily be forgiven to think of a Samuel Beckett play, where the end beckons but never nears. There were some in Goa for instance, who felt that The Shah Commission’s report was a perfect present for this Chaturthi season. Apparently not:

As one can clicks this link , Ganesha too, is not to be protected from the mining lobby, a few upper caste, well-heeled families, who now outsource their greed and theft, to, a constituency that by design is  now referred to as ‘mining-dependent people’…Given that it was part of the same play, it was not unlikely, that yesterday too, perhaps even at the same time, the renowned Centre for Science and Environment and indeed, some 30 journalists from Goa, Karnataka and Maharashtra, were given a taste of just how much is being done to make blatantly illegal mining become ‘legal’…

All these actions follow what Goa’s pro-environment lobby has been saying for some time, that the mines are illegal and they should be shut down forthwith. As can be read they have argued their case cogently – even to the extent of seeking the Supreme Court’s intervention to recognize the findings of The Shah Commission and do nothing more than implement its recommendations.

The Sept 29 edit in Herald from Panjim, given its long and trusted tradition of either sitting on the fence, or trying to run with both hares and hounds, was surprisingly forthright, saying 35,000 crore rupees was looted by X number of Goan mining operations, that the Goan people want that money back, as simple as that, and all the fat cats should stop trying tricks to wiggle out of the mess and continue the mining as if nothing happened.

The edit mentions the 80 year old woman who blocked a mine. That’s nice: her name is Dora, she’s my mother and I couldn’t be a prouder son. She blocked the mine being operated by Dinar Tarcar, a well-known politician and suave man about town. When we found out in 2008 through our sources in the Mines Department that the mine was patently illegal and operating without any licenses, it was her suggestion that the mine be blocked.

That too was interesting. There were several others arrested with her, including a Salesian priest and a well-known anti-mining activist. Mysteriously only Dora, her daughter and her family retainer had cases filed against them, and had to go several times to court to answer trumped-up charges. The case dragged on four solid years and still failed to break Dora’s resolve that the blatantly illegal mining had to stop.

In all this absurdity, lies a journalist called Sujoy Gupta, who once edited the Herald and actively assisted the BJP come to power and assert the constitutional right of some families to mine, only to dump them the next day, mission accomplished, to head The Goan, a weekend newspaper that claims to be the authentic voice of Goa. Gupta is better known in pro-environment circles, as the man who filed a 500 crore lawsuit against an anti-mining activist in Goa, a suit one may add that seems to have mysteriously disappeared. He’s also been the main front for preaching the case for ‘legal’ mining.

Dora of course insists that any industry that willfully takes away forest and water cannot be legal, and the rest of us in her family concur with that. But the old bird has a great sense of humour, I’ll give her that…

This Tarcar fellow’s mine was illegal she asks me?
Yeah, I reply.
This Gupta fellow only wants legal mining?
Yeah, I say.

And this Gupta fellow filed a suit for 500 crore against Saby because Saby was only writing about illegal mining when his own boss, that Timblo fellow, was actually doing ’legal’ mining?

Yeah, I tell her, wondering where she’s going with this crazy logic.
So this Gupta fellow is actually only against illegal mining?

You could say that I reply.

She hasn’t finished. So now you tell me he’s a big shot with a lot of clout and what not and edits this big paper that’s only speaking for Goans?

Good, she says, so you ask this Gupta fellow and his boss, that Timblo fellow, whether he’ll help me file a 500 crore suit in Goa – because I can’t travel all the way to Kolkata – against this Dinar Tarcar fellow for illegal mining, and falsely harassing us for four years. Tell him when we get the money, we’ll share it among the people of Cawrem and Maina and reforest Tarcar’s illegal mine…

Nice idea Mom I say, I’ll tell the guy…

- Hartman de Souza

Friday, September 14, 2012

An open letter to Kasturirangan & Co


Dear Dr Kasturirangan, 

Aspersions have already been cast that the Kasturirangan panel will dispose what the Gadgil panel has painstakingly proposed! Given controversial birth of your panel, it will take a leap of faith for the concerned, within and outside of the Western Ghats, to convince themselves that your panel will prove it otherwise. Such contention may be rhetorical at this stage, but has every chance of becoming a reality should the recent soundbites in the media were to come true.   

There are reasons for citizens to be skeptical. The Gadgil panel had termed Western Ghats extremely ecologically sensitive region and hence suggested restricted mining and other development activities. You have been quoted in the media: 'The Kasturirangan panel will hold meetings and consider all issues, since the Western Ghats is important to the country.' How different it is from what the Gadgil panel had said? It had held wide consultations and considered each of the issues in the Western Ghats on ecological and scientific merit. It will be a challenge for your panelists to read the findings differently!

Your panel will have a lot to prove itself. First, through your report you would need to provide 'reason' to persuade skeptical and skittish citizens that the government had enrolled the best available expertise into the task of ecological (re)assessment. Second, your panel ought to 'reason' not only theoretically, but also empirically, that it was not engaged in a political practice but in a scientific inquiry aimed at connecting a defensive state (read the Ministry) with its attentive citizens. Third, your panel must provide a modicum of certainty that the panel, conducted with taxpayer support, has fulfilled its obligation to the people and the ecosystem under reference.      

But your panel can do a world of good by avoiding to nitpick the WGEEP report and instead focus on how indeed the Western Ghats must, given its regional and global ecological significance, be governed. Should such a sense (?) prevail, the panel would have gone a step ahead in proving its worth. After all, the very idea of creating the WGEEP in the first place was to recommend the setting up a Western Ghats Ecological Authority. If the then Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh had his way, he would have announced such an authority in 2010 itself. But he was advised to take-a-step-at-a-time and creation of the Gadgil panel was a step in that direction. 

Would the Kasturirangan panel be courageous enough to take the second strep?

Dr Sudhirendar Sharma

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Mini hydel causing macro scars in the Western Ghats

There is a rush to flood the Western Ghats in Karnataka with mini hydel projects, each with an installed capacity of around 25 MW. Promoted by public sector Karnataka Renewable Energy Development Limited and built by private players, as many as 836 mini hydel plants with a combined capacity of over 4,000 MW have been under various stages of implementation, from consideration to construction. Numerous such projects shall soon dot the rivers like Netravathi, Kumaradhra and Gundias on Dakshin Kannada map. Reports indicate that nearly 108 mini hydel projects are at various stages of completion.

Since these can be built without undergoing any environment impact assessment and consequently do not need environment clearance as well as mandatory public hearing, there is literally a ‘gold rush’ to scar (see picture) the picturesque Western Ghats with such power units. Though one would imagine these units to be non-obstructive and non-offensive in nature, dams to create the desired head discharge are at times as high as 10 meters.

Simply assuming that a mini hydel project will be green and clean by default could indeed be untrue. Sample this: the 24.75 MW MHP by AMR in Perla Village and another 24.75 MW MHP at Shemburi by Ritwick Energy near Mangalore are in reality on big project worth 50 MW whereas as per the Project Design Document submitted to UNFCCC for claiming Carbon Credits, both were 'separate' mini projects. Much to everybody’s surprise, Netravathi river has been dammed with huge submerge upstream of the structure, sudden release from which had drowned three youths last year.

Same is the case with the Maruthi Power Gen dams in Hassan, which were shown at two different locations on paper (to avoid forest clearance) but were being executed as one huge structure on ground. The construction and tunneling activity has caused extensive damage to forests and wildlife habitat.  On the other hand, Kukke I Project near Hosmata is unique as it will not only submerge houses and endanger a critically endangered plant that has recently been rediscovered in the area but will submerge part of another MHP unit upstream as well.

Since mini hydel projects do not need mandatory public hearing, an informal public hearing was organised under the aegis of the Save Western Ghats Movement by Prakruti and SANDRP on Aug 4-5, 2012 at Kukke Subramanya, a small temple town near the origin of the river Kumaradhara in Dakshin Kannada district. As many as 60 affected farmers, fishermen, activists, researchers and scientists took part in the discussions and issued a ‘Subramanya Declaration’ that called for greater regulation of the sector alongside punitive action for those violating the norms.

Mini hydel projects can be clean, green and welcome provided the sector is regulated and efforts made to involve local population in planning and implementation of such schemes with a caveat that the communities have access to power generated through MHPs in their area.

Parineeta Dandekar

Saturday, July 28, 2012

Whose playground is Western Ghats?

Democracy is a numbers game connecting people with legislators and parliamentarians. While people play this game once in every five years, for the intervening period the dice remains loaded in favor of the elected representatives. In peoples' faith they hold the dice but quite often end-up playing to serve vested interests. Else, legislators in Karnataka and Kerala assembly would not have been up in arms that 'development projects' will be halted in the Western Ghats by UNESCO heritage tag and the controversial WGEEP report respectively. Branding anything 'anti-development' is the dominant political discourse of our times.

Could legislators have taken a different stance had peoples' voices been echoing in their ears? It is anybody's guess but it would surely have made a difference because at the end of the day it is the 'constituency' that matters for the legislators. With this in mind, the idea of a Member of Parliament Forum on Western Ghats was mooted by SWGM in 2009 and first attempts to set up such Forum were also made. However, it was in 2010 that then Environment Minister had announced the setting up such Forum under the aegis of the Ministry of Environment & Forests. Ever since the WGEEP had a session with the Forum nothing much has been heard.

The reason for elected representatives to be short-sighted and small-minded has much to do with a lack of accountability towards the people they represent. It is more by design than default that peoples' real concerns rarely echo in the corridors of power. Given the way our society thinks and works, the task of sustained connection with legislators has often to be through petitions, protests and panels. Since much of this has limited impact, civic campaigns and peoples' movements remain the next best option. But literature is replete with evidences that campaigns/movements neither make legislators see 'logic' in (orchestrated) public voice and nor do governments capture 'reason' emanating from science (WGEEP) being presented to them.      

Without doubt, judicial activism does provide temporary reprieve in such situations. However, in an era marked with 'consistency deficit', 'governance deficit' and 'compliance deficit, court orders and judgements run the risk of poor compliance. In a democratic set-up, undermining peoples' power could indeed be suicidal. Couple of us who worked with an MP to get the National Green Tribunal bill passed in the Parliament with desired amendments can indeed vouch for the change that can be brought by engaging with the elected representatives. It is high time MP Forum on Western Ghats and/or State Legislators Fora on Western Ghats are revived to get some sense into the politics that is obsessed with 'economic assessment' of Western Ghats. After all, Western Ghats could not be allowed to be the playground for the politicians alone!   

Thursday, July 12, 2012

SWGM: Reinvent or Perish!

The resurrection of the loose-knit Save Western Ghats Movement in 2009 was indeed a shot in the dark, few of us who conceived it knew it as an 'art of the impossible' (recall the Bamboo musicians in the picture!). Any work of 'art' creates a 'dent', we knew. The unpredictable spontaneity did the trick, both at Goa and at Kotagiri. The unrealistic demand, at least at that time, of a 'western ghats ecological authority' was a work of 'art' for us. Like any work of 'art', there ought to be at least a buyer for it. The connoisseur in Jairam Ramesh saw value in putting money on it. The day he bought our art work at Kotagiri in 2010, we were left penniless. Not penniless in monetary sense but in every other sense of the term.!

First, our 'art' was redrawn to suit to the minister's 'drawing room'. Perhaps not without reason, the fine lines of an 'authority' were converted into hard lines of a what was construed as a 'panel'. Second, an imaginative piece of work was converted into a 'process', with a definite timeline to deliver the end-product a'la WGEEP Report. Pinning hopes on the leftover of the original, the movement laughed and cried at each stage of the process (post 2010), missing out on the next possible opportunity to get back on the drawing board for its next 'creation'. Living in a state of strange schizophrenia the SWGM instead has been lost in the illusory notion of being close to achieving the unachievable!

Many may disagree but any 'movement' is 70 per cent work of 'art' and 30 per cent 'commerce'. Since the first work of 'art' was bought at Kotagiri, this ratio has been reversed. What was spontaneously unpredictable could now be predictably contrived - the movement has literally been swallowed by time-bound activities. What is not written in the project document is most unlikely to be considered, cause-effect linearity determines the logic of any 'action'. No wonder, it is a losing battle that the 'movement' is currently engaged in, if at all. Unless the current batch of 'proponents' go back on the drawing board, commerce-driven gainful engagement will ensure that the SWGM only celebrates its 'past', something to 'w(g)eep over!
      

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Heritage Tag: Milestone or Millstone?

By tagging the Western Ghats to the World Heritage List, UNESCO has brought to fore the hitherto low-pitched battle between environmentalists and the development juggernaut. While environmentalists have lauded the move, industrialists have denounced it as an anti-development measure. The Federation of Indian Mining Industry has gone to the extent of saying that: 'India's growth is being stalled' whereas Deccan Herald editorial opines that 'the new tag has defeated such naysayers'.

The heritage tag to the Western  Ghats does improve its TRP but getting the rating translated into tangible actions to protect the fragile ecosystem could indeed be far-fetched. Such perceptions are not without reason because the 39 sites of the Western Ghats selected as heritage sites have all been governed under the existing environmental regulations and legislation. It is unlikely if the heritage tag alone would suffice to accentuate compliance of existing protective measures....more

Sunday, July 1, 2012

WGEEP report is nobody's baby?

Is there a hidden message the government has conveyed by dropping Prof. Madhav Gadgil from the National Advisory Council (NAC)? Has persistent efforts by Gadgil to ensure that the report of the Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel (WGEEP), of which he has been the chairperson, be accepted by the Ministry of Environment & Forests been negatively construed by the government? It is seemingly clear that Gadgil's stance as an activist, to get the report accepted, hasn't gone well with the government.

Sources indicate that at this crucial juncture, with a close eye on the 2014 general elections, the government wants the NAC to work in close synergy with the UPA to provide a clutch of actions that can deliver political goodwill to keep the 'aam aadmi' image of the ruling coalition alive in popular perception. With Food Security Bill, Communal Violence Bill and the Land Acquisition Bill already mired in controversy, the NAC can least afford controversies and dissension on additional matters.

Insiders believe that the WGEEP report, despite public opinion been sought on it till July 5, would remain an exercise in ecological academics. If it could not be accepted when Gadgil was member of the NAC, the chances that anything dramatic may happen when he is no longer member of the august council seems remote. While the Western Ghats may not be politically volatile region, accepting WGEEP recommendations may have serious implications (with likely spillover to other regions) on the growth agenda of the government.  Jairam Ramesh, who was instrumental in setting up the panel, has already expressed his fears that the WGEEP report may get junked.